Comments on Comments #30
November 26, 2008
Here are some responses to your comments, prior to the Thanksgiving Holiday. Blogging may be light during the next few days as I try to catch up on reading, then again, blogging may be prolific. Who knows.
++
Mike Gogulski 1955Design left a comment on Metablogging, in regards to my inquiry about the Twitter badge in the sidebar.
Mike and 1955Design report that they see the Twitter badge correctly. Must be something local to my machine, although it was visible at first.
If readers are seeing it (and I’m not) then I’m not worried about it.
+++
I’ve had a few technology-related issues in recent months. This morning, this website was haxxed. It may be a WP security issue, but appears like it might be a server hack. In any event, some of my readers have been kind enough to offer advice for dealing with these problems. Although I haven’t needed their help, it’s great to know that people who are essentially strangers are willing to help me out. That’s voluntaryism.
++
Mike Gogulski points out that Taxation is still theft no matter how many logical fallacies you employ was getting some attention on reddit|Anarchism. I’m glad there’s discussion, but a lot of the comments were obvious trolling. I don’t follow reddit, digg, etc., although reddit and stumbleupon have been driving some traffic to my site lately.
++
On the metablogging note, Billy Beck @ Two–four.net recently linked here. I got a lot of traffic from that hit. I’m very happy people are noticing and reading my blog. If you don’t read two–four regularly, I suggest that you do.
Traffic for November looks to exceed 4,000 absolute unique visitors according to AWSTATs. I’m getting anywhere between 50-150 unique visitors each day, and approximately 500 pageviews, daily.
++
Brad left a comment on No Nation Ever Taxed Itself Into Prosperity, Either:
What are you and RG trying to solve? It sounds like a battle of “I have read more books than you so I’m more qualified.” RG sounds like a politician.
I think your argument of taxation brings no good is simple enough. There just needs to be a better way to collect taxes instead of just taking it through income taxes or raising taxes on certain products (like yachts). I like a flat federal retail tax. This way the government can only get as big as the market will let it.
LOL @ the first part of the comment. I sensed it was kind of going that way, and asked RG to post his commentary at his own blog (he doesn’t have one) or to feel free to correspond with me via e-mail. He has yet to do so. He left a number of comments that I’m trying to put together into a coherent post, rather than piecemeal comments/responses, they’re not going unnoticed or unchallenged.
The second part of Brad’s comment is WRONG.
I oppose a flat tax for the same reason I oppose any tax. Taxation is theft, and it even though a flat tax is somewhat more transparent (allegedly) it still amounts to ransom for permission to live. In a free society, that is intolerable.
Brad is a budding libertarian, so there is hope for him, yet. The problem is buried as a hidden premise to “There just needs to be a better way to collect taxes”, which is, “Government is the only entity capable of providing certain things, from which it follows that taxes are necessary for the provision thereof.” I could probably write a book on that topic.
++
I’ll respond to one of RG’s comments
Also — as much as you have studied economics, I find it hard to believe that you support the market-distorting mortgage tax deduction. Granted, you believe nobody should ever pay taxes and we should live in caves. But given current circumstances, surely you can see that the tax deduction is nothing more than a transfer of wealth from renters and homeowners (e.g. no mortgage) to people who are somewhere on the 30-year journey to homeownership.
Taking off my anarchist hat, for a moment, from a policy perspective, it seems far more reasonable that a deduction be based not solely on mortgage interest paid, but rather on the total monthly housing expense. In this manner, no matter where you are on the 30-year amortization continuum, or even if you rent a home, you’d be eligible for a deduction based on the monthly payment. This proposal might also base the deduction on the property value instead of monthly payment, in order to reduce/eliminate the incentive to remain indebted.
Insofar as the current incentive serves as a transfer, it falls primarily on the renters, since homeowners at one point benefited from the deduction (or, if they paid cash, had the opportunity to benefit from it). I don’t support it as a general principle, I’m just trying to point out that repealing that deduction would be the single largest increase in effective tax rates, probably in the history of the world.
But wait: If reducing tax burdens for some people “distorts” the market (I agree that it does), is it not also true, that raising tax burdens for some people is also distortionary?
Yes, that must also be true. That’s one of the points I’m trying to make in that series of posts.
++
Enjoy the holiday weekend.
Possibly related posts:
- Metablogging: Thanks for the Traffic!
- Obama Promises Less Dreadful Tax Day
- Comments Are Fixed (Mostly)
- Comments Broken
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.
2 Comments so far
Leave a Comment
If you would like to make a comment, please fill out the form below.
Dave
I agree with the taxation is theft mentality. I was not on the path of a flat income tax. I was more on the retail/ transfer of goods. Like a 5% tax on all goods goes to “the man” and closing the IRS down all together. I know it does not solve the whole problem but its a step in the right direction. This money would go to cover the annual budget. I know you probably have figures of how much the U.S spends vs. how much the GDP is and even a 5% tax would still be short. There are so many programs that need to be shut down to begin with which is another story. Doesn’t this put more control back into the citizens hands because now we can hold onto our money and decide how we are going to spend it instead of the government just taking it from us w/o a receipt? I know the root of the problem is something you commonly talk about and its letting the FED print up money whenever it wants w/o sticking to a budget.
Sometimes I think about the conversations we have had over the years and I wonder how much government/taxes/The Man would be acceptable to you. Then I saw “free society” in your sentence.
The other night I was watching MTV and they took a “Sweet 16″ rich kid into some jungle and made them live with a jungle tribe to show them what real living is all about. The tribe lives off the land. Has no currency. No wars. They trade with neighboring tribes. They have a chief who got the job just because he’s old. I watched the show and I thought of the tribe as a “free society.” Is this kind of what you mean as a free society?
If not can you please describe what your free society would look like or at least a glance on how it would operate. If I missed a post let me know.
Budding Libertarian! I probably watched too many Ron Paul videos on YouTube this year.
Dave
Sounds like your getting more traffic. You should try using a couple more plugins on your site. The ones I use are:
“Word Press Related Posts” – What this one does is add up to 5 more posts from a similar category or a random one of your choice after your current post. Look at any post on my site and you will see 5 more after all of them. Helps in “deep linking” for Google and more stuff for people to read.
“Dagon Design Sitemap Generator” and “Google XML Sitemaps” – These produce a place which lists all of your posts/categories ever. Both plugins help with deep linking and the xml sitemap is well liked by the search engines. Here is mine – http://thetop10reasons.com/sitemap
“RSS Footer” – This one produces your full article and links back to your site. This way nobody can steal your content w/o the links embedded in it. From time to time I get a notice from some random site that took my feed and uploaded it w/o my permission. At least this way you know who might be stealing it and now you have a link back to your site.
“WP-PostViews” – This one is a must for your site. This will put a widget in your sidebar and keep track of your most popular posts of all time. Check it out on my sidebar. This way it keeps your all time greatest posts fresh in a way.
After I put these plugins in my traffic went up by 25% in one month.
Rage!!